Don't post the first thing ChatGPT gives you: write a Black Friday offer that sounds like your small business
2026-11-18
Your Black Friday offer should not be the first thing ChatGPT writes for you. The first draft is a fair starting point, but it sounds like every other business in Australia, and your customers have seen that email dozens of times this week.
This is an opinion, and I hold it firmly: the tool is not the problem. The one-line prompt is. If this post stops even one small business from posting the first thing ChatGPT gives them, it has done its job. Below is a before and after, and a four-step method you can run this week.
Why ChatGPT's first draft makes small businesses and small-medium enterprises sound like everyone else
ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini predict the most likely next words. If you type "write a Black Friday offer for my business", the most likely words are the ones thousands of businesses have already used. Massive savings. Don't miss out. Limited time only.
It isn't being lazy. You gave it nothing to work with. It doesn't know that your customers are mostly local, that you hate the word "unlock", or that your margin on the featured item is thinner than you'd like.
This matters more for small businesses than for big ones. A large retailer can win on price and reach. SMEs mostly win on being recognisably themselves. If your offer reads like a template, you've given away the one advantage you had.
A first draft and a finished Black Friday offer, side by side
Here is an example of a typical business, not a client. Picture a sole trader electrician in Sydney's inner west who wants to fill December with switchboard and safety switch checks.
The first draft, from a one-line prompt:
Black Friday Mega Sale! Unlock massive savings on our electrical services. Don't miss out on this limited-time offer. Book now and save big this Black Friday!
It says nothing. No price, no job, no reason, no person.
The finished version, after the method below:
Every year I find the same thing: safety switches that don't trip when they should. It takes about 40 minutes to test them and check your switchboard, and most people never book it. For Black Friday week only, I'm doing the full check for $120 instead of my usual $180, for the first 12 homes. I'll tell you straight if nothing needs fixing. Reply to this email or call me on the number below. Licence no. [your licence number]
Same business, same week, but a very different message. The second one has a specific job, a real price, a cap and a human voice. It sounds like a tradie talking, not a campaign.
Two cautions that are your call, not the AI's. First, a "was" price must be a price you genuinely charged. AI drafts love to invent one, and the ACCC has guidance on two-price comparisons under the Australian Consumer Law. Second, licensed trades usually have to show a licence number in advertising, so check your own state's rules before you send anything like this.
A four-step method to write a Black Friday offer that sounds like you
This is what you take away. It takes about 20 minutes.
1. Give it your voice. Paste in two or three real emails, texts or posts you've written to customers. Say: "Describe how I write in five bullet points. Then use those points for everything that follows." Check the description. If it says "professional and engaging", it hasn't heard you yet. Try again with more samples.
2. Give it the facts, including the unglamorous ones. The offer, your price floor, the cap on numbers, the dates, and what you will not discount. Do the margin sum first: what the item costs you, what you'd make at the discounted price, and how many you'd need to sell to come out ahead. Retailbiz's coverage of small retail and Black Friday is a useful read on why that sum matters before you commit. Then hand the AI the answer, not the question.
3. Give it a real reason. "Because it's Black Friday" is not a reason. "Because December is quiet and I'd rather fill it with regulars" is. Customers can smell the difference.
4. Ask for three versions, then edit by hand. Pick the best one and do the human pass below. Don't ask the AI to "make it better" five times. Each round sands off a bit more of you.
The human edit before you hit send
Read it aloud and check these:
- Would I say this sentence to a customer standing in front of me?
- Is there a number a customer can check (price, cap, date)?
- Have I deleted every "unlock", "elevate", "game-changing" and "don't miss out"?
- Is there anything claimed that I can't deliver?
- Is any "was" price one I have genuinely charged?
- Does it say who is writing it?
The fourth line is not optional. AI will happily promise "same-day service" or "free shipping" because those phrases are common in offers. You are the one who has to honour them.
Sometimes the right offer is a smaller one
A good prompt can't rescue a bad offer. Plenty of small businesses are quietly stepping back from deep cuts. SmartCompany has reported on small businesses rethinking discounts to protect their margins, and Dynamic Business has a guide for SMEs on when to discount and when to walk away.
My view: if you can't write an honest reason for the offer, you may not need it. A capped bonus for regulars, a bundled service or an early-access message can sound more like you than a percentage off. Sole traders, tradies and contractors in particular can offer a limited number of booked slots instead of a price cut.
If you're still working out the bigger picture, the BFCM playbook for small businesses and SMEs covers the planning. Once your offer is written, a sales-week campaign in an afternoon shows how to turn it into email, SMS and socials. And if you want different offers for different groups, see personalised offers without a data team.
What to do differently this week
Stop treating the first answer as the answer. Treat it as a rough draft from a keen new starter who has never met your customers. Feed it your voice, your numbers and your reason. Then edit it like it's going out under your name, because it is.
Get a second pair of eyes on your offer
If you'd like help setting up AI so it writes the way your business talks, that's what our AI adoption work at MILabs is for. Bring your current offer draft and the margin on the item you're discounting to the first chat, and we'll look at it together. Discovery is free, no obligation from the first chat. Every enquiry gets a reply within 24 hours.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
- Why does ChatGPT write such generic Black Friday offers?
- It only knows what you tell it. With no detail about your customers, margins or how you talk, it fills the gap with the most common sales language it has seen.
- What should I give ChatGPT before asking for a Black Friday offer?
- Three things: two or three real examples of how you write to customers, the facts of the offer (what, price floor, limits, dates), and one real reason you are running it.
- Can sole traders and tradies use this method too?
- Yes. A tradie or contractor with no shop can offer a capped number of booked jobs, a bundled service or a loyalty bonus. The method is the same: facts, voice, constraints, then a human edit.
Related
read these next- How to power your BFCM sales with AI: a playbook for small businesses and SMEs
- AI software on sale: when the annual discount is a trap for small businesses
- Reach the right customers: how small businesses and SMEs can use AI to pick who to target this sale
- A sales-week campaign in an afternoon: email, SMS and socials with AI
